MY MOTHER NAMED ME SUNSHINE
  • Home
    • About Me
    • Precariously Unsheltered: Witnessing the Eviction Cycle In Waterloo Region
    • Nickles and Dimes: Seeking Change
    • Cutting Through the (Seemingly Bovine) 'Fecal Matter'.
    • Realizing the Right: Municipal Policy Responses to Encampments >
      • Human Rights & Housing Fights - Presentations - Realizing the Right >
        • Rethinking Municipal Approaches - Human Rights and Housing Fights
        • Human Rights and Housing Fights: Municipal Encampment Responses
        • CAEH Conference Ottawa 2024
      • Written Content - Projecct Outputs - Realizing the Right >
        • Waterloo Region Snapshot - Realizing the Right: Municipal Policy Responses to Encampments
        • Rethinking Municipal Policy Responses to Encampments: Building a Human Rights Approach in Ontario
      • On the right to adequate housing - By Peter Elgin (2020)
      • Open Letter: ​Seeking aid for Unsheltered in face of current Extreme Weather Crisis - 2025
      • Unsheltered: Emergency or Public Health Crisis - Where are we? >
        • ERP: Regional Policies
        • ERP: Provincial Acts
      • Social Justice Housing Rally
    • Municipal Meeting Pages
    • Advocacy Resources - Broad
    • Social Media
  • Home
    • About Me
    • Precariously Unsheltered: Witnessing the Eviction Cycle In Waterloo Region
    • Nickles and Dimes: Seeking Change
    • Cutting Through the (Seemingly Bovine) 'Fecal Matter'.
    • Realizing the Right: Municipal Policy Responses to Encampments >
      • Human Rights & Housing Fights - Presentations - Realizing the Right >
        • Rethinking Municipal Approaches - Human Rights and Housing Fights
        • Human Rights and Housing Fights: Municipal Encampment Responses
        • CAEH Conference Ottawa 2024
      • Written Content - Projecct Outputs - Realizing the Right >
        • Waterloo Region Snapshot - Realizing the Right: Municipal Policy Responses to Encampments
        • Rethinking Municipal Policy Responses to Encampments: Building a Human Rights Approach in Ontario
      • On the right to adequate housing - By Peter Elgin (2020)
      • Open Letter: ​Seeking aid for Unsheltered in face of current Extreme Weather Crisis - 2025
      • Unsheltered: Emergency or Public Health Crisis - Where are we? >
        • ERP: Regional Policies
        • ERP: Provincial Acts
      • Social Justice Housing Rally
    • Municipal Meeting Pages
    • Advocacy Resources - Broad
    • Social Media
Search by typing & pressing enter

YOUR CART

Pillar 1:
​Decentre Policing and Enforcement​

“No Place Else to Go: Surveying the Human Rights Experiences of Encampment Residents in Ontario” is a seven-part report series. 
Rather than releasing our survey findings as a single publication, as we did with our policy report, we are sharing this research incrementally through a series of interconnected reports. Alongside an overview of the research process and findings, the series includes individual reports dedicated to each of the human rights pillars explored through the survey. We hope this approach allows for each theme to be examined in greater depth while fostering broader community dialogue.
Picture
The reports in this series are each authored by different members of the project team. While each report can be read independently, together they provide a comprehensive account of the project's methodology, evidence, and findings concerning human rights and encampments in Ontario.
Picture

Part 2/7 of the "No Place Else to go" Report Series

Pillar 1:
Decentre Policing and Enforcement

By Regan Sunshine Brussé and Laura Pin

View ALSO:

  • Background: The Human Rights Pillars
  • Survey Framework​
  • Survey Methodology
Picture

View this report as a (.PDF)


About This Pillar 


Pillar 1 emphasizes that homelessness should be addressed as a social and systemic issue rather than a criminal one. When municipalities center police and bylaw enforcement in their responses to encampments, they often do so at the expense of service provision. Enforcement-led approaches can create fear and uncertainty among people experiencing homelessness and may discourage engagement with outreach services, which can become associated with enforcement activities.

Practices such as forced removals from encampment sites, routine surveillance by authorities, and the issuance of citations or tickets contribute to the criminalization of homelessness. These actions can disrupt people's lives and increase physical, emotional, and psychological harm. Indeed, forced displacement is considered so harmful that it has been described as a "gross violation of human rights" in international human rights documents (Farha & Schwan, 2020, p. 19).
Picture
To better understand people's experiences with policing and enforcement, our analysis of the survey data focuses on the criminalization of people experiencing homelessness, particularly in relation to displacement and interactions with police. Specifically, the analysis was guided by the following exploratory questions:
  • Are people forcibly displaced from encampments on public property due to encampments being rendered illegal through bylaws or other policy tools? 
  • How are people affected by displacement? 
  • Have people experienced criminalization and/or surveillance by police and/or bylaw for engaging in day-to-day survival activities?


​What We Heard


Forced Displacement from Encampments
People staying in encampments frequently described being displaced from their camps. Overall, 61% of survey respondents reported experiencing at least one incident of forced displacement, and many described multiple or ongoing displacements. Respondents overwhelmingly reported that displacement was carried out by enforcement authorities, with bylaw officers involved in 75% of displacements, police involved in 64%, and private security involved in a further 27%.
Picture

Survey participants characterized evictions as a routine and normalized part of daily life. For example, one respondent stated that forced evictions occurred "every day Monday to Friday. The city makes us leave all the time." Another explained, "Anybody who didn't want us there told us to leave... almost every week for a month, two months."
Although some municipalities had formal procedures for providing notice before displacement, several participants described being displaced with little or no warning, sometimes while they were away and unable to safeguard their belongings. One person explained, "They waited until me and my partner went to the store and when we came back everything was gone." Another participant reported being hospitalized for three days and returning to their encampment to find that "everything I owned was dumped into a city dump truck" after the site had been cleared during their absence and without prior notice. Some participants also described forced displacement occurring during extreme weather or in the middle of the night.

Frequent and unpredictable encampment clearings create a constant sense of insecurity, fear, and instability. In turn, this can make it more difficult for people to access services, as they may be reluctant to leave their camps unattended for any length of time.
Picture
When people were forced to leave encampments on public land, no reason was sometimes provided. For example, one participant described how bylaw officers "didn't give proper notice, didn't explain." Others reported receiving vague explanations that did not correspond to specific bylaw violations, such as "too many emergency calls," "complaints from neighbourhood residents," or simply being told that they "aren't allowed to be here." When a specific rule or regulation was cited, it was most often the Trespass to Property Act. Participants described being told they were trespassing by being present on public lands, including parks, parking lots, and natural areas such as ravines

Importantly, when people were forced to leave an encampment, they rarely had an immediate alternative shelter option. While some may have been offered a space in an emergency shelter, as discussed in the Pillar 3 report, most participants reported significant barriers to accessing shelters. These included a lack of available spaces, concerns about safety, the need to stay with a partner or service animal, disabilities that made congregate sleeping arrangements difficult to tolerate, and a lack of gender-specific options for women.

Yet emergency shelters were often the only option presented. As one participant explained, "When told to leave [my camp], I asked where, other than a shelter, I could go. I was told to move around but realized I would be told to vacate other parks." For most participants, forced displacement resulted in the continuation of unsheltered homelessness rather than connection to permanent housing or even placement in an emergency shelter.

Content continues below...
Picture

Rights become difficult to meaningfully exercise when survival itself is in question.


Impact of Forced Displacement
Forced displacement was associated with a range of physical, emotional, and safety-related harms that undermined stability and limited individuals' ability to access and maintain connections to essential services. Participants described experiencing "mental and emotional stress," "losing safety," and being "left high and dry" because of forced displacement. One survey respondent described the emotional toll of repeated displacements in detail:

"When I first became homeless, I was getting pissed off a lot. [It] was like they were following me. I set up at the escarpment [for] two days and then would have to move. This happened five to six times. ​This is why I moved to the railway tracks because they don't have jurisdiction."

​This account illustrates how repeated displacement created significant emotional distress and compelled the participant to relocate to a more hazardous location. In an effort to avoid further displacement, the participant moved to an area near railway tracks, highlighting how enforcement practices can inadvertently increase exposure to safety risks.
Picture
When asked about the consequences of being forced to leave an encampment, participants described a range of significant harms. Three-quarters reported the loss or destruction of personal property, with several specifically noting the loss of identification documents and mobile phones during encampment removals. Two participants described their belongings as having been "bulldozed." Participants also described losing deeply meaningful personal possessions, including "my father's ashes" and "personal items that were irreplaceable ... like family photos." These losses are particularly profound, as such possessions often represent important connections to loved ones, personal histories, and sources of identity. Beyond their material value, the destruction of these belongings can have lasting emotional impacts and further compound the trauma associated with displacement.
In addition to losing personal belongings, 48% of survey respondents reported losing contact with family and friends following a forced displacement, 44% reported losing connections to social services, and 41% reported losing connections to health services. Some participants provided additional details about these disruptions. For example, one participant explained that after a displacement during which they lost their phone, they "missed phone calls with OW workers and other workers and also missed appointments."
Picture
Displacement can also increase vulnerability to direct harm, particularly for women and gender-diverse individuals. As one woman explained:


"Due to being without shelter and having no belongings, I have been vulnerable and in situations where I've been physically and sexually abused."

Collectively, these experiences highlight how forced displacement can destabilize already precarious living situations by severing essential support networks and increasing vulnerability to further harm and victimization. The disruption caused by eviction made it more difficult for people experiencing homelessness to meet their basic needs and ultimately move toward more stable housing or shelter options. As one participant explained, "[you] can't get ahead because [you're] constantly starting over."
Many respondents reported being told that their eviction resulted from violations of municipal rules governing where encampments were permitted. This was particularly notable among respondents in Hamilton, who reported a significant increase in forced evictions following the repeal of the City's Encampment Protocol By-law in April 2025, which had provided some guidance regarding where people could shelter outdoors. Respondents expressed frustration at having nowhere to go:​
Picture

​“Just that I cannot be here because it is not allowed”

“So can I ask a question?  Where are encampments allowed?  Nowhere.
​Not in parks.  Unless you have a friend's backyard.”

Experiences of Criminalization and Surveillance
Beyond displacement, people staying in encampments experienced various forms of criminalization and surveillance, often simply for being present in public spaces or engaging in day-to-day survival activities. Sixty-eight percent of participants reported being carded, that is, being stopped by police near their encampment and asked what they were doing. A further 60% reported being threatened with a ticket at or near their encampment, while 34% reported actually receiving a ticket.
Picture
Content continues below...
Picture

These decisions not only undermine the
dignity and safety of affected individuals,
​but also stand in direct contradiction to the
​obligations inherent in a rights-based response.

Some people staying in encampments described neutral interactions with enforcement personnel. For example, one survey participant said, "The security guards that we deal with are actually decent people who treat us like humans. When we show compassion to them, they show compassion to us. Most of them anyway." More commonly, however, participants described their interactions with police and bylaw officers in negative terms, characterizing them as frequent, intrusive, and, at times, threatening. These accounts suggest that encampments are often approached as sites of enforcement rather than places where support and services are needed. Numerous participants reported experiencing what they described as "fishing" expeditions, in which officers requested identification "just to see if anyone might have a warrant" or conducted purported "wellness checks" while "[making] everyone come out of structures and run names." Another participant described a similar encounter: "[Officers] asked us for ID. Mine was stolen, but they tried to run our names. [We] had no warrants, but they still told us to leave." A third participant described bylaw officers and police as "always pushy, always forceful." Together, these accounts illustrate how routine interactions with law enforcement were often experienced as forms of surveillance and criminalization rather than efforts to enhance safety or provide assistance.
Picture
Survey participants reported both receiving tickets and being threatened with tickets for engaging in everyday survival activities, including simply being present in public spaces. For some, ticketing was a routine occurrence. One participant stated that they had received "enough tickets that I can't count," while another noted that they were ticketed "pretty often." The most commonly reported infractions related to trespassing. However, participants also described receiving tickets for activities such as loitering, garbage accumulation, and public urination. As discussed in the Pillar 2 report, many individuals had limited or no access to alternative means of meeting these basic needs. These accounts suggest that enforcement practices often penalize behaviours associated with survival while experiencing homelessness rather than addressing the structural conditions that give rise to them.
Picture

The issuance of tickets, and the threat of receiving them, created substantial emotional stress for survey participants. Several people described the threat of tickets as "constant" and "daily." One participant explained, "[We're] told that we have to move... if we're still there when they come back, we get ticketed. We never know when they would come back." Most participants lacked the financial means to pay such tickets.


Key Takeaways


Overall, the survey found that people staying in encampments frequently experienced forced displacement by bylaw officers, police, and private security personnel, sometimes through the enforcement of neo-vagrancy bylaws and sometimes without a clear explanation for why they were being required to leave. Because people sheltering in encampments rarely have access to alternative shelter options, forced displacement often results in continued homelessness and increased vulnerability.
Forced displacement by enforcement authorities causes a wide range of significant harms for people experiencing homelessness. Many survey participants reported losing property as a result of being forced to leave their encampments, including essential survival items such as tents as well as personally significant possessions. Displacement also made it more difficult for people to maintain connections with informal support networks, such as family and friends, and formal supports, such as housing workers. Following displacement, participants were often pushed into more remote and less secure locations, farther from essential services. Location can be a major barrier to service access, as people experiencing homelessness often have limited means of transportation. Relocating to more remote areas can increase isolation and exposure to violence, particularly for women and gender-diverse people who may become disconnected from their support networks, services, and communities.
When asked how municipalities could better support people staying in encampments, survey participants offered clear insights into how enforcement could be decentered in encampment responses. Many participants focused on creating pathways that would allow people to remain legally in encampments. One individual simply stated, "Decriminalize homelessness!" Others emphasized reducing the presence of enforcement personnel. For example, one participant called for "less cops," while another advocated for "security that actually helps." Participants also offered more specific suggestions, including: "create designated encampment zones offering services and not forcing relocation every week"; "have some sanctioned spots"; and "sanction an encampment with staff, security, and outreach.
Picture
Top-down police- and bylaw-led responses to encampments are strongly associated with the criminalization of people experiencing homelessness. Participants experienced criminalization through informal stops and carding, being threatened with tickets, and receiving tickets for largely minor bylaw infractions and/or simply being present on public lands. The issuance of tickets, and the threat of receiving them, made it more difficult for people to undertake basic survival activities and created substantial emotional stress for survey participants,
People are routinely evicted from encampments despite lacking alternative shelter options. Removing people from an encampment on public land without an immediate and compelling justification constitutes a human rights violation (Farha & Schwan, 2020). Yet, as our survey documented, people were frequently forced to move and were often not given a reason for their displacement, limiting accountability and transparency in interactions between enforcement authorities and those being displaced. Typically, when people are forced to leave an encampment, they lack alternative shelter options and continue to experience homelessness, often with fewer supports and resources.
Enforcement activities lead to evictions while undermining other human rights priorities. Rights become difficult to exercise meaningfully when survival itself is in question. The consequences of enforcement activities and encampment evictions create ripple effects that compromise people's ability to advance each of the human rights pillars. Enforcement centres policing and law enforcement in encampment responses, makes it more difficult for people to meet their basic needs, and creates barriers to accessing social services. It also makes it impossible for people staying in encampments to participate meaningfully in decisions that affect them and fails to uphold Indigenous rights. In the context of encampments, forced evictions often intensify the crisis by displacing people, disrupting stability, and making it more difficult to maintain connections to supports and services (Brussé, 2026).
Encampment evictions deplete local resources that could be redirected toward more constructive responses. Evictions result in the repeated expenditure of significant service agency, volunteer, and community resources. Municipal funds spent on enforcement activities and encampment cleanups could be more effectively redirected toward proactive site maintenance, such as waste disposal, and supports rooted in a human rights-based approach (Brussé, 2025). Redirecting these resources toward prevention, harm reduction, and housing-focused supports would likely produce more effective and humane outcomes for people experiencing homelessness and the broader community.
Picture

White text on a purple-to-black gradient background reads: ‘No Place Else to Go: Surveying the Human Rights Experiences of Encampment Residents in Ontario.’

< Part 1/7
​​
Building the Evidence: Survey Design, Data Collection, and Research Highlights

Part 3/7>
Pillar 2: Addressing Conditions in Encampments and Basic Needs

Picture

More pages from "around here":  ​

  • ​Precariously Unsheltered: Witnessing the Eviction Cycle In Waterloo Region​
  • Understanding the Growing Divide : A Look at Local Data
  • ​Safe Tenting Zones and the Waterloo Encampment Case - By David Alton​
  • Sheltering with Dignity: ​Safe Tenting as a Human Right
  • Continuing to Evict Despite Knowing Better... Why?

Because there must always be music...


Website (often left semi-) built, (occaisionally) designed, and (spuradically) managed by
Regan Sunshine Brussé